Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The Gold of Golding

A while back, I noted in a post in passing that I had recently read (almost) all of William Golding's fiction. Somebody suggested I provide a summary or ranking, and I thought I would do this, but based on his relevance for fans of D&D. 

This may not be quite as eccentric as it sounds. Golding is one of the few 20th century mainstream posh literary greats whose work is consistently also imaginative, creative and exciting enough to please a speculative fiction fan. And I would suggest in particular that if you are a fan of Gene Wolfe you will see quite a lot of similarities between their approaches. 

Which, though, of Golding's books are the most gameable? Which are the most Relevant To Our Interests?

Here, I rate his books first on the basis of quality (from my Goodreads reviews) and then I rate them according to how inspiring they are for a DM, how readily they can be stolen from for ideas for NPCs, monsters and adventure locations; and how gameable they would be as a campaign setting in their own right. Here goes, in the reverse chronological order in which I read them:

The Sea Trilogy (comprising Rites of Passage, Close Quarters, and Fire Down Below). I read these in quick succession, and consider them to be collectively one of the masterworks of the 20th century, although this only becomes apparent as you go - the final volume is by far the best, and achingly good, but you have to read the first two to really appreciate it. The book is really just a fictional journal of an eager young man concerning his sea voyage from England to Australia, set during the Napoleonic era. But it is a rip-roaring, funny, touching, tragic, exciting and moving read. Here are my reviews of the respective volumes:

  • Rites of Passage: There is no doubt that Golding was a great novelist. The way he immerses the reader in the early 19th century nautical setting is truly extraordinary (it is infinitely better than the nearest comparable book I could think of, Thomas Pynchon's Mason & Dixon) and the dialogue, characterisation and pacing are pitch-perfect. The way the plot suddenly pivots from comedy to tragedy is done with real daring and aplomb. And yet I was left dispirited by the bleakness of the ending. All Golding's endings are bleak, but this one felt almost nihilistic - and I found that more demoralising than thought-provoking. With that said, a 4-star Golding novel is easily worth a 5-star one by any other author! (****)
  • Close Quarters: This book suffers from being the middle part of a trilogy - nothing is resolved. And the setting (a ship damaged and slowly rotting, and only able to move at a snail's pace) is in itself depressing, and this depression seeps into the reader's consciousness as he reads. But with all that said Talbot is a wonderful narrator, the characters are fabulous, the dialogue pitch perfect, and there are some truly great moments (the approach of the 'French' ship and the vision of the 'sea monster' being the obvious things everybody highlights, and they are highlights for a reason). And for all that it at times feels depressing, it is also deliciously funny. (****)
  • Fire Down Below: This is by far the best of the Sea Trilogy, and perhaps my favourite of Golding's novels. In it, we see the payoff of the work done in the previous two volumes, as we now see so clearly what Golding has been carefully painting for us - the ship, the characters, the social web among passengers and crew, and the period in which the tale is set. It is a work of great humanity - it's funny, tragic, nuanced, gentle, warm, romantic, at times dark, and written with all of the craft Golding had accumulated over the decades. It is entirely worth getting through volumes one and two (which are in their own right highly readable, if in places flawed) in order to be in a position to enjoy what is surely one of the under-appreciated masterpieces of the 20th century. (*****)
The wonder of the Sea Trilogy is its sense of verissimilitude. Golding was a sailor and fought in the navy during WWII, and it shows - he knows what it is to be on a ship. But he uses all of his great imaginative power to situate the reader in the age of sail. You are there. What I also love about it is how it focuses on the interactions between the characters on a year-long voyage, when they have literally nobody else to speak to other than each other. At the end they are like a family - both loving and hating each other in equal measure. 

Inspiration - 3 bec de corbins (it is mostly inspiring for maritime campaigns, I would say); Stealing-fromness - 3 bec de corbins (the greatness of these books lies in the relationship between the characters, and there are some really memorable ones who would make great NPCs); Gameability - 3 bec de corbins (I think a campaign set on a sailing vessel would be great, but a lot of the books concern the boredom and frustration of being many months at sea - I don't think this would be very useful for a D&D campaign)

Average - 3 bec de corbins

Pincher Martin. This is a horrible, frightening, riveting book about an evil man who finds himself stranded on a rock in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean after falling off a ship. Or does he? No spoilers.

My Goodreads review: 

Golding was a genius and a visionary and each of his books is a little miracle of inspiration - something no other author could have imagined, let alone written, and written so well. This is a modernist masterpiece: a depiction of the individual wrestling with the fact of his own existence - and easily the equal of anything written by Conrad, Bellow, Melville, or Greene. (*****)

For RPGs, there is less to work with here, with the proviso that the point of Pincher Martin is that his rocky home is just a tiny islet - probably significantly less than 100 yards in diameter. He is alone in the ocean. An RPG campaign in which the PCs are marooned on a much bigger island a la Robinson Crusoe would find much grist for the mill here, as Golding devoted a huge amount of thought to island survival and how a person finding himself in that environment would get by and plot rescue/escape.

Inspiration - 3 bec de corbins (chiefly for 'PCs as maroonees' motif); Stealing-fromness - 1 bec de corbin (there is literally one character and one almost-empty location); Gameability - 2 bec de corbins (the setting is not gameable at all unless you conceive of it as something altogether different from what it is - a much bigger island, or else a gateway to the Underdark or similar)

Average - 2 bec de corbins

Free Fall. This is also a horrible, frightening, riveting book about a semi-evil man who finds himself, er, stranded in a POW camp during WWII. Like Pincher Martin, he is not a nice man. But he perhaps redeems, or at least justifies, himself. Unlike Martin he is not a psychopath, but is formed by the awful circumstances of his upbringing. You understand all of the bad decisions he makes. The themes are in a way more disturbing, though. In Pincher Martin we are alone with the thoughts of a very selfish man bent on survival. In Free Fall, we see how a flawed individual can wreak havoc on the people around him. And we also see how ordinary, everyday, petty cruelties inflicted on us can cause us to inflict cruelties of our own. 

My Goodreads review:

Golding is simply a brilliant writer, and this is him at the peak of his powers - a near-perfect example of the modern novel and its elaboration of the general in the particular. The characterisation and dialogue are wonderful; the prose in general is peerless. I was captivated from start to finish. (*****)

Again, for RPGs, there is not much to work with, as the setting is very quotidian. But the sheer sordidness of some of what goes on is translatable, I think, into a setting containing orcs, goblins, and other monsters.

Inspiration - 1 bec de corbin; Stealing-fromness - 3 bec de corbins (there are some truly hideous and malevolent NPCs here, the best of them being Rowena Pringle, surely the inspiration for JK Rowling's Delores Umbrage - she'd be a great evil sorceress); Gameability - 1 bec de corbin (the book is really very much about the tortured interior life of a very conflicted soul)

Average - 1.666 bec de corbins

Lord of the Flies. Come on. It's Lord of the Flies.

My Goodreads review:

I first read this book when I was about 12 or 13 years old at school, but have not touched it since. Remembering very little about it second time around, and without the text being parsed through the jaded worldview of a half-competent English teacher, I was simply stunned by how good it was - a kind of miracle of storytelling. Golding could be accused of hastening the denouement a little. But that would be to pick at fleas - the book well deserves its classic status. (*****)

Lord of the Flies is buried beneath layer upon layer of cultural memory (at least if you're English - pretty much everybody here reads it in school) but, strip that away, it's simply one of the Great Novels. There's a reason why it's famous. And it's amazing to consider that it's the first book he really published. I am surprised how rarely it is mentioned in RPG circles, too. It is a very gameable book - the post-apocalyptic scenario, the deserted island, the hints at the existence of ghosts and demons, the violence. You could actually almost make a module out of it, straight out of the box, as it were: the PCs are a bunch of kids stranded on an island after a plane crash. Go!

Inspiration - 4 bec de corbins (chiefly for the desert island setting and the hints at the supernatural); Stealing-fromness - 3 bec de corbins (probably the island itself and the 'Lord of the Flies' motif rather than any of the characters); Gameability - 4 bec de corbins

Average - 3.666 bec de corbins

The Scorpion God: Three Short Novels (comprising 'The Scorpion God', 'Clonk Clonk', and 'Envoy Extraordinary'). These are a mixed bag, mostly interesting for their settings than their narratives. In this respect they are superlative, but the experience of reading them I found a little 'meh'. The last in particular, while a nice idea (the ancients discovering steam power) doesn't do much as a work of fiction. As RPG inspiration, on the other hand....

My Goodreads review:

These three novels each try to capture the mindset of people living in the distant past - in ancient Egypt, pre-historic Africa, and Rome respectively - and succeed as fascinating (and sometimes very funny) thought experiments, but without any emotional heft. By the far the standout is the middle story, 'Clonk Clonk', which is the most complete tale and the one which manages (despite its ostensibly more distant and unusual setting) to engage the reader best. The other two stories are worth reading, but ultimately have the feeling of being parlour tricks. (***)

As with The Sea Trilogy, Golding here reveals his peculiar gift for imagining himself to be in very distant, alien times and places. The way he imagines life among an ancient Egyptian royal family, or a stone-age tribe, is truly extraordinary. Most writers just can't even get close to doing it. He creates people and relationships which feel precisely of their time and place, rather than transplanted moderns or cyphers for current personality types. This is one of the things that made him a genuine Great, of course.

Inspiration - 4 bec de corbins (for the way he captures very alien ways of life, and of thought); Stealing-fromness - 4 bec de corbins (just read the eponymous novella if you want to picture life in an alien temple, underdark drow fortress, etc. - or 'Clonk Clonk' if you want to imagine life among a non-human humanoid race); Gameability - 4 bec de corbins

Average - 4 bec de corbins

The Inheritors. This book was actually recommended to me by a commenter here on the blog, a few years ago now, and that person is a generous and blessed soul, because this is truly a wonder. Everybody's Top Ten Books of All Time list would vary somewhat at the time of asking, but there are certain books that you just know in your heart will always be there, and this is one of them. If you have never read it, do so at once. The story has a simple premise: neanderthals first encounter humanity. But what a job Golding does of thinking that premise through to its awful conclusion. 

My Goodreads review:

A great novel will make you understand human nature better, and in a different way. This novel is very great, because it does this with stark purity by forcing us to confront humanity from the outside, as it would be perceived by minds that are not our own. This is an achievement that truly merits being labelled a work of genius. That it is also a work of lyrical beauty and terrible tragedy makes that achievement more unlikely, and more impressive still. (*****)

The Inheritors is also at the pinnacle of Golding's D&D-adjacency. I mean, it's literally about psychic neanderthals. But the way it brings a stone age, or perhaps we should say pre-stone age, world to life is truly incredible. Again, as with The Sea Trilogy, you are there. It is both a way to situate your own mind in a prehistoric world, but also an inspiration to imagine realities totally other than yours. If Golding can conjure into being a setting as rich as this, why can't you?

Inspiration - 5 bec de corbins; Stealing-fromness - 3 bec de corbins (there is a lot in there by way of little vignettes that could make their way into a campaign); Gameability - 4 bec de corbins (you could definitely use it as the material basis for a stone age, or ice age, campaign)

Average: 4 bec de corbins

The Spire. This is Exhibit A for my argument that there is a Golding-Wolfe connection to be drawn somewhere - it has everything: an unreliable narrator, weird gaps and allusions that cause you to never quite be sure what is going on; sheer oddness and a way of pulling the rug out from under you without warning. 

The story is on the face of it one of madness - it's about a man who is trying to build a cathedral and wants the spire to be very tall, so tall that its foundations will not be able to support it. But as with a lot of Golding's best work it is also a total immersion into a different time - in this case, medieval England. For a fantasy fan, it has the virtue of feeling totally authentic; unlike your average fantasy setting, the characters come across as truly medieval people, with medieval minds and ways of relating to one another. This makes it a wonderfully rich source of creative inspiration to help make a setting come alive.

My Goodreads review: 

An equally bizarre and beautiful book that trades on an odd mixture of allusions, gaps, and - let's be frank - a bit of over-the-top melodramatic romanticism. It is typically billed as being a fable about prideful folly, but I found as ever that Golding's portrayal of his main character is subtle and humane; he's by no means a villain, and indeed has many qualities to be admired. A wonderful book, full of mystery. (*****)

The real value of The Spire is the way it brings its setting to life in a way that an DM will surely wish to emulate.

Inspiration - 5 bec de corbins, Stealing-fromness - 3 bec de corbins (I do love the descriptions of the cathedral under construction and often thought that a half-built, gigantic place of worship would be a cool idea for a dungeon); Gameability - 3 bec de corbins (the whole setting would make a good adventure site within a wider campaign)

Average - 3.666 bec de corbins

Er, that's it. I have not read Darkness Visible, The Pyramid or The Paper Men. I've heard the latter two are not very good. The first one, I will read at some point.

A discussion point: are there any other mainstream literary greats whose work has any value for a D&D DM, beyond the value which all fiction has for quickening the imagination, understanding the world better and inspiring the mind? 

Thursday, 12 November 2026

I Dunno, Mike; Or, the Nerd Superiority Complex

You may have heard that M. John Harrison, author of the Viriconium books among others, has recently won the Booker Prize (the UK's premier general 'posh' contemporary literature prize) for his latest novel, The End of Everything.

Fair play to him, and everything - I've generally loved the books of his that I have read - but it's at times like these when I feel my Nerd Superiority Complex coming on most intensely. 

I mean, here is the wikipedia synopsis for the novel, to try to help elucidate what I mean:

The setting is South East England in the near future after a crisis has disrupted society. Monstrous and mysterious iGhetti have appeared in the City of London. They are large translucent columns which distort reality, creating "bad patches" of anomalous and unstable environment. Central government seems to have collapsed and Europe is now a "lost continent". But many features of society remain and the main protagonist, Phillip Tennent, makes a living in Dalston-on-Sea by beachcombing for artefacts spawned by the iGhetti which wash up on the shore. 

 He finds an artefact which develops human characteristics: growing limbs, starting to speak and developing a relationship with Tennent's Aunt Marnie, who is an elderly artist with dementia. The story follows Tennent and his aunt as they both make journeys from the coast to London – Tennent trying to sell the artefact while his aunt is driven from their community after killing a teenager.

I dunno what you make of that; maybe to somebody who has never read any post-apocalyptic or dying Earth fiction before, that sounds original and innovative? But to my eye it just looks like a much, much less interesting and much more cringingly on-the-nose version of Viriconium or any one of another dozen or so 'end of everything' style books I could name. And this feeling of on-the-noseness and seen-it-all-beforeness just sets deeper as one reads on:

The novel's catastrophe is triggered by the arrival in the United Kingdom of the unexplained iGhetti – "We know nothing about their actual intentions," says one character. "They may not even know we are here." – whose presence can be read as symbolising artificial intelligence, the climate crisis, political chaos, Britain's withdrawal from the European Union, late-stage capitalism or a combination thereof. Placing their focal point in London's financial district was a deliberate choice by the author: the germ of the story was the 2008 financial crisis and the "rage" it made him feel. Harrison was originally unsatisfied with the name but embraced it after realising the ambiguities it evoked: the explanatory "I get it", the acquisitive "I get", the wealth of the Getty family, the i-products of Apple Inc. and the Freudian ego. In writing the book, he said, his aim was depict the "explanatory collapse and epistemological collapse that you see in societies that have suddenly lost their grounding".

I mean, iGhetti? Really? Because it sounds like 'I get' and calls to mind 'the wealth of the Getty family' and Apple? That's what we're going with? That's the level of subtlety and inventiveness we're talking about?

It seems sad and wasteful to me that a man could write a series of works which are as graceful, interesting, elusive, multi-faceted and evocative as Viriconium and then be reduced later in his career to a glorified pun like 'iGhetti' only to win the Booker for it. That in itself is almost like the plot of a Philip Roth novel (aging outsider author writes self-parody; accidentally gets lauded by the literary elite). But it also indicates just how devoid of taste and intellectual curiosity mainstream intellectuals tend to be in comparison to the genuine nerd. Genuine nerds - the people who love a genre so much that they want to push its boundaries as far as it can go - are the real trailblazers. The literati follow distantly in their wake. 

Personally I think the average dying Earth OSR setting has much more of interest by way of depicting 'explanatory collapse and epistemological collapse that you see in societies that have suddenly lost their grounding' than it seems is possessed by The End of Everything. No doubt M. John Harrison is a great stylist. But can we not aspire to anything greater than iGhetti? Is it that for which our ancestors fought and died? 

Nerds - you, the extreme nerds, the nerds of taste, the nerds who have read so many nerd books that nothing impresses them any more outside of those most recherche corners of the nerdosphere, I salute you. You are the true intellectual vanguard. You are the educated elite. Feel your superiority, and embrace it!

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

The Quiet Fuguelike Joy

In the comments on my previous post (about creating a 1-mile hex map of Japan with the help of Claude) somebody popped up to say: 

I don't understand how it scales up your ambitions for campaign settings - creating a map has never been the bottleneck. More hexes to fill means more human-work.

I found this interesting. Don't get me wrong - I understand the point being made. Laboriously filled in a 1-mile hex map of Japan does not on the face of it reflect a more ambitious campaign setting, which would require, if anything, the opposite (namely, big, sweeping, large-scale ideas and inventiveness). 

But I would like to stick up for this type of project, on the grounds that 'more human-work' is by no means necessarily a bad thing. I happen to think that keying a 1-mile per hex map of Japan would be a very pleasurable activity in its own right. It would be a life's work - if it took 5 minutes to key every single hex it would still take you decades, working at evenings and weekends. But would that be any more of a waste of time than doing jigsaw puzzles, playing video games, or watching TV?

Activitiy like this has its own pleasure. This is often misleadingly and ignorantly labelled 'mindfulness', although it's really the opposite of that. It is really more to be understood as the pleasure of being in a creative fugue-state, where the external world ceases to matter for a while and the conscious mind becomes absorbed in the completion of a focused task. This is the brain-state which we enter when drawing a picture, writing, practicing a musical instrument, and so on, and although it is not filled with intense pleasure it does produce a mild and continuous sense of tranquility, relaxation, and enjoyment.

A month or two ago I made a post advocating world building as a hobby in its own right, and this type of task - keying huge and detailed maps - is clearly a very concentrated and distilled version of that activity. Just now I asked Claude to make me a set of hex maps of Kyrgyzstan, at country, region, and district level. Tell me that the urge to get keying doesn't come over you when looking at this stuff:








Friday, 6 November 2026

Oh Satan, Is There Anything You Can't Do?

Drunk on power this afternoon, I commanded my demonic robot slave Claude to make some hexmaps. And I was impressed with what it came out with. I told it to produce a single 24-mile per hex hexmap of Japan for use in an OSR sandbox, then a 6-mile per hex map of each of Japan's regions (Kyushu, Shikoku, Chugoku, Kansai, etc.), and then 1-mile per hex maps of every prefecture. And it duly spat out amazingly detailed, usable, and - one must conceded - aesthetically pleasing stuff.

Here is the 24-mile per hex map of Japan (it even apologised that since some of the sea channels in Japan are less than 24 miles wide it was not able to map them accurately, and at its own initiative placed special sea borders between hexes at such locations):



Here are examples of two of the regional 6-mile hex maps (for Shikoku and Tohoku):




And here are two examples of individual prefectures (Kochi and Ishikawa) at the 1-mile hex level:




Now, you can tell these are AI-produced (note for example how the little insert map, showing where what is depicted fits into the bigger picture, just depicts a random, sliced-off corner of Asia and then sea all around - a human being would never do that). But still, you have to grant that, with about three simple prompts and 30 minutes it is a wonder that it was able to come up with all this. And it is incredibly useful; it would potentially completely revolutionise the way I prepare a campaign, and also scale-up my ambitions for what I could create in terms of campaign settings by several orders of magnitude. I would just love to get cracking keying in those hexes.

And yet, and yet, it is funny how something so marvellous can at the same time fail to satisfy. Last weekend, I happened to have created my own map of a campaign setting, the idea for which had popped into my mind almost fully formed. I won't talk about the substance here now, but here at any rate is the (unfinished and unlabelled) map I did on Worldographer:


It took me a good few hours across two evenings - let's say, at least 6 times as long as it took Claude to map out Japan in beautiful 1-mile hexes in painstaking detail. And it looks nothing like as nice as what Claude came out with. But I was much more pleased with it, because it was mine. OK, ok, so I used a software programme to do it - I didn't hand draw it. But it was my effort and labour that went into it. And doing the coastlines for those islands, not to mention the rivers (have you tried to draw rivers in Worldographer?) was fiddly and took some time to get right. I felt good about what I had done, and satisfied. It's not perfect, and it will take more work to fill everything in and get everything how I want it. But it - forgive me being pompous - feels good in my soul to have made it. 

I have over the years made a number of posts riffing on the fundamentally Satanic nature of AI art and writing. But here I come back to the main observation I made several years ago. Like the Angrborn in Gene Wolfe's The Wizard Knight, the problem, the real problem, with what Claude and its ilk produce is that, while technically incredible, lacks the capacity to be loved. As I put it back then:

We examine [what AI creates] as we would a constellation of stars - a thing that, however beautiful, is impenetrable to emotion. We do not love it in the same way that we can love a real painting by a real person, or at least recognise such a painting to be loveable in some sense to somebody even if it's not to our personal taste. We humans can love all manner of things - think of how deeply a child loves a stuffed toy, a hardworking parent loves his or her comfortable bed, a football fan loves his team, or a young person loves an item of clothing. But we do not love AI art. It is inert to our affection.

Saying that I love my own map would state the position too strongly, but I have an affection for it that no amount of highly functional and visually appealing Claude maps could possibly kindle in my heart. I want to make things, insofar as it is possible to do so, that are mine - or, with respect to things I cannot myself make, to obtain human-produced work that has the capacity to be loved. This is my position, which I find I have to stick to. 

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

Unicorns Are Not Just Rhinos

One of my children has a book - you will have seen the type of thing - called something like Amazing Facts About All Kinds of Things, or Isn't Science Amazing, Kids?, or Let's Be Amazed at How Amazing All the Amazing Things in the World Are. It's a big long list of questions, essentially, with 'expert' factoid responses. 'Does anything eat seagulls?'; 'What is the biggest number anybody has ever imagined?'; 'How do hovercraft hover?'; 'Why is Pluto no longer a planet?'; 'Why are plants green?'; 'Do pangolins poo?' etc.

Anyway, I was flicking through this book idly the other day and came across a question about unicorns - I think it was something along the lines of 'Where did the myth of the unicorn come from?' - and found myself becoming mildly irritated at the answer. What the book told me was that the myth of the unicorn most likely came from rumours about rhinos, which by a process of Chinese whispers (I don't think the book used that expression exactly) gave rise to the notion that there were horses running about with horns on their heads.

I always become mildly irritated when these sorts of explanations are offered for the origins of myths and legends - usually offered a la Michael Caine peering over his spectacles to announce that 'not many people know that', or Rafael Benitez insisting 'It's a fact'. The origin of dragons was people discovering old bones that belonged to dinosaurs. The origin of elves, dwarfs, fairies etc. was a cultural memory of other species of hominid. The origin of centaurs was the Greeks first encountering steppe nomads riding around on horseback. The origin of sea monsters was people seeing whales for the first time. And so on. 

I become mildly irritated on such occasions for two reasons. 

The first is that it denies to humanity its capacity to imagine, and to make up stories. Why on earth would anyone think that human beings would be incapable of dreaming up dragons, or unicorns, or centaurs, of their own accord, merely on the basis that they lived in the past? The impulse to explain mythic creatures in this way is curiously unimaginative - even imagination-denying. The entire premise seems to discount one of the most obvious features of the human intellect, which is that it can envisage things that are not real. 

The second is that it is so brutally prosaic and banalifying. Do we really think that the myth of a dragon, or a unicorn, was simply created on the basis of the existence of old bones in the ground, or rhinos, and had nothing to do with the symbolic, the expressionistic, the poetic, or even the spiritual themes with which those creatures are imbued? Is the reason why the dragon myth caught on that it explained bones in the ground, or is it rather that the idea and image of the monster resonates with us somehow at a level we are not quite consciously aware of?

The reduction of unicorns to rhinos is, in other words, precisely that - a reduction. We did not dream up a unicorn because somebody's uncle Alf talked to somebody's aunt Bessie who talked to somebody's cousin Fred who talked to his sister-in-law Harriet who talked to her friend Samantha who said she had seen something running around on four legs with a horn on its head. We dreamed them up, and continue to dream them up, because they were once imagined, and because once imagined they came to mean something. We consider them significant in semiotic terms and not because of an origin story that seems neatly tied together. And our ancestors created them not because they were stupidly trying to parse rumours of rhinos, but because they were imaginative, and creative, and liked stories. 

And the same is true across the piece. We do ourselves a disservice, and make the world and our place in it much less interesting, if we search for common sense or pseudo-historical explanations for why we possess the myths we possess. We possess them because creating myths is one of the things we do. 

Wednesday, 28 October 2026

Art You're Scared to Look At Directly

I have recently been going through a bit of a Fighting Fantasy trip, having found some old books in my attic roughly six months ago. I have all of the Sorcery! books on order from eBay (I only had The Shamutanti Hills in my possession) and plan to try to collect the initial run of 50. In my day it was a treat to be able to afford a book - most of my reading was taken from the shelves of the local library - so I had about ten in total. I'm hungry for more.

Anyway, one of the books I have is called The Talisman of Death, and last night I decided to page through it, not having enough time to give it a play through. And I was amazed to find an extremely powerful wave of nostalgia washing over me as I suddenly remembered its illustrations - pictures I had not looked at in at least thirty years and probably more, and which I had apparently totally forgotten about, all suddenly became as vivid and fresh to me as they had when I had first seen them all those decades ago.*

Is there a word for that feeling? I said 'nostalgia' but that is not quite right. What I mean is the feeling of suddenly encountering an artefact that triggers memories that had apparently been forgotten. I had not given a second's thought to these pictures for a considerable stretch of my life. But when I looked at them, I knew them - they felt as though they had been etched into my soul, and had just been waiting to be discovered.

A lot of the illustrations are just really great, in an extremely 80s sort of way:







But there is also among them a category of illustration that I vividly remember from my youth - art that was too scary to look at directly. You may know what I mean. You're nine years old. You have a vivid imagination. You're reading a book which has somewhat dark and 'grown-up' themes. And then you turn the page and see pictures like this:



These freaked me out as a young boy. It wasn't that they were particularly grotesque (although they are a bit). It is rather that they made me imagine things, and the things they made me imagine were terrifying. Looking at them made me afraid - not of what was in the pictures, but of what they made me imagine. I knew that to look at them would set my brain whirring, and that would set it off on a journey somewhere horrible indeed. 

Even the relatively non-grotesque art in this book has something of that quality. There is a generalised eeriness that is difficult to shake off. See, for instance, here:



To this day they give me a vague sense of unease. There is something horrible about them - 'horrible' I think being the appropriate term. They are not the stuff of conventional horror. But they are nasty. They make you feel uncomfortable and weird. You don't enjoy looking at them. They are creepy and odd.

Perhaps one has to be 9 years old to truly feel this way, and perhaps the reason I feel this way about them now is simply because I am channelling my 9 year old self. But perhaps I'm wrong. When was the last time you looked at art that scared you to look at it directly? Not because of what it depicted, but because of what it made you imagine? No adult-oriented recommendations, please - keep it clean.

*The illustrator for The Talisman of Death was called Bob Harvey. He died a few years ago, and it seems never had much of an internet presence, but he was apparently prolific. 

Thursday, 22 October 2026

Big Good Guy Monsters Reviewed and Ranked

The D&D Silver Age (the period beginning at the end of the 80s and segueing into the mid-90s) were my formative years as far as the hobby goes. I was raised on 2nd edition, Dragonlance, Forgotten Realms, Dark Sun and Planescape. 

This was the era when narrative was everything and an RPG campaign was idealised as resembling a sort of interactive high fantasy novel. And as such, it created an implicit category of creature which I think of as the 'big good guy monster' - a sort of combination of Gandalf the Grey, the dragon from Neverending Story, and Yoda, who was supposed to exist to rescue the PCs from danger if a deus ex machina were required, give them quests, and/or dispense wisdom or plot advice. 

These guys are peppered throughout the AD&D 2nd edition Monstrous Manual. Generally they are of a similar type. They tend to be able to fly (so as to appear at a moment's notice); to be able to heal, dispense wishes, and things of that nature; and to be able to find or 'know' things as needed. They also tend to be powerful, so as to be able to act as an ally in a desparate battle against a red dragon (or whatever). 

Here, I review and rank them. My criteria are:

  • The Big Good Guy Monster must have 7 or more HD
  • The Big Good Guy Monster must be lawful good, neutral good or chaotic good (and not merely have a chance of having such an alignment)
  • The Big Good Guy Monster must be L size or greater 
  • The Big Good Guy Monster must not be a dragon (because otherwise the list would be dominated by dragons)
The creatures which meet these criteria, by my count, are: couatl, djinni, firbolg, reef giant, storm giant, ki-rin, lammasu (lesser and greater), werebear, guardian naga, phoenix, shedu (lesser and greater), androsphinx, titan, treant. I was in half a mind to discount treants arbitrarily because they didn't quite seem like a Big Good Guy Monster initially, but then I reflected on how ents treants appeared in The Two Towers to save the day in various guises, and changed my mind. 

They are here rated for interestingness, originality, and usefulness, with the latter defined on the basis of its usefulness for a typical Silver Age campaign, if one were of a mind to run such a thing (I emphasise I am not - this is just for fun):

Couatl - This is a vaguely central american monster that is supposed to put us mind of Quetzalcouatl and all that jazz. It inhabits jungles, deploys psionics, and is described as 'one of the most beautiful creatures in existence' (an assertion that is not exactly borne out by the illustration). It is a good place to start, as it is in many ways archetypal as a Big Good Guy Monster. It is powerful, super-intelligent, can fly, is telepathic, can go invisible, etc. It has all the characteristics one would want in a creature that you wish to use to deploy in a 'The eagles are coming!' moment, or as an otherwise powerful DM Mary Sue-style ally. It is a bit boring, though: all we're really told is it is intellectually curious, hates evil, and is generally left alone in its jungle home.

Interestingness: 2 bec de corbins; originality: 4 bec de corbins, usefulness: 4 bec de corbins

Djinni - We all know what a djinni is. This perhaps suffers from bearing the great weight of immense baggage - it either conjures images of the 1,001 Nights, or of Barbara Eden, or of Robin Williams, or perhaps of (boo, hiss!) Will Smith. In this respect it is a bit difficult to take it seriously. Boringly, there is nothing in the description about lamps or granting wishes. Rather, the djinni is described as a creature of elemental air which is able to perform various magical feats such as creating illusions or summoning whirlwinds. It does, however, have a suit of handy abilities when acting as a sidekick for the PCs, as would able to transport them around, create fake gold and treasure, and so on. 

Interestingness: 2 bec de corbins, originality: 2 bec de corbins, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Firbolg - This is a sort of giant hairy woodsman a little like Beorn but without the shapeshifting ability - or, perhaps, like the Ghost of Christmas Present from the Muppet Christmas Carol. I can't say it is particularly impressive or interesting. It can do various tricksy things like creating fools gold or altering itself, and is 'cautious and crafty'. One can imagine the PCs discovering a friendly firbolg village in the forest and relying on its inhabitants for age in a very generic Silver Age campaign. 

Interestingness: 1 bec de corbins, originality: 2 bec de corbins, usefulness: 2 bec de corbins

Reef Giant - This is one of the better of the giants, occupying both an interesting cultural niche (imagine a gigantic member of the front row from the Tongan rugby union side) and a useful in-game one (being the only Big Good Guy Monster suited for an aquatic or coastal campaign). Reading the description one imagines a kind of combination between said rugby player, thingy from Moana, and Ariel's dad from The Little Mermaid - a trident wielding solitary figure who inhabits a great underwater mansion. Reef giants lack many abilities though - they mostly create whirlpools.

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbins, originality: 3 bec de corbins, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Storm Giant - Storm giants are meant to invoke Zeus, but also - in common with many Big Good Guy Monsters, Gandalf. They are big blokes with big beards who live in castles in the clouds (or occasionally underwater) and have many weather- or lightning-related abilities. Again, one imagines that the position one would occupy in a campaign is a sort of free-standing powerful ally who the PCs might request to intervene in battles with Big Bad Evil Guys or, who, perhaps, commands them to do quests necessary for the saving of the world. The image of a cloud castle is itself a nice one, and I do quite like the idea of having a map with a Storm Giant palace on it somewhere. There is nothing wrong with Big Good Guy Monsters, even in an OSR campaign, if they are billed as stand-offish, mysterious, powerful entities one would do well not to cross. 

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbins, originality: 2 bec de corbins, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Ki-rin - The ki-rin is a kind of celestial Chinese reptilian unicorn with golden scales (fun fact: in Japanese kirin is also the word for a giraffe, presumably because of its resemblance to the mythological creature). Its D&D iteration, however, is one of the ultimate Mary Sues - it is a perfect flyer, telepathic, psionic, magical (as an 18th level magic-user) and extremely powerful in a fight. And it also possesses all sorts of other useful abilities, including being able to create magic items, go to the Ethereal and Astral planes at will, create perfect and near-permanent illusions, and so on. And they are more or less designed with the Silver Age model in mind. We are told in the description that 'Ki-rin come to the aid of humanoids if asked properly or if such beings are faced with a powerful, extremely evil being. Ki-rin believe in self-improvement, though, and do not casually come to a humanoid's aid except in the most dire of circumstances.' We are also told that 'Ki-rin spend most of their time pursuing their own affairs. They often monitor the activities of powerful evil creatures and beings. If such beings become too malevolent, the ki-rin act against them. Ki-rin may reward allies or needy individuals by creating food and valuables.' If that doesn't scream RECURRING PLOT DEVICE to you with the volume turned up to 11, you must be stone deaf. 

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbins, originality: 2 bec de corbins (it is really just a rehash of other similar beings), usefulness: 5 bec de corbins

Lammasu (lesser and greater) - The Lammasu is cursed with a faintly ridiculous-looking piece of art (how could they mess up such great source material as real-life pictures and statues of lammasu?) and, I have to say, a too-transparent shtick. Lammasu are more or less written into the game to provide the D&D with a Get Out of Jail Free card if he feels the PCs are in too much danger and their plot immunity is threatened.   Hence, 'Since lammasu are concerned for the welfare and safety of good beings, they almost always enter combat if they see good creatures being threatened, in the way least likely to cause harm to the good beings.' A lot more could have been done with the concept, frankly. They can heal people, fly, and do telepath....... zzzzz

Interestingness: 2 bec de corbins, originality: 1 bec de corbin, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Werebear - A bit of a change of pace. Werebears, controversially, do not fly and are not telepathic. They exist to perform a Beorn-function, or else possibly act as a powerful sidekick: 'Only the rare individual (usually young) can be coaxed into joining a band of adventurers. Werebears may join an adventuring group as guides, provided the money is right and the job is agreeable.' I'm sure that this device exists in ten thousand fantasy novels, though right now I can't quite think of one.

Interestingness: 2 bec de corbins, originality: 1 bec de corbin, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Guardian Naga: There are scholars and sages who may dispute whether the guardian naga qualifies as a Big Good Guy Monster. The description is terse: it guards the treasure of 'a like-aligned being's treasure or some evil'. But it does meet the criteria, so I shall include it. And it must be said that the idea of a lawful good guardian acting as sentinel over some ancient evil is an intriguing and highly evocative one. Again, I could see myself putting that in a dungeon or on a hexmap somewhere. 

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbins, originality: 3 bec de corbins, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Phoenix - Phoenixes er, fly and are telepathic. Other than that, they are almost unfairly powerful - 20 HD, many, many spell-like powers, etc. With all of that said, they are rescued from a by-the-numbers feel by two things: the self-immolating mechanic and rebirth, and also the fact that their feathers can be used to make magic items or sold for vast sums. Clearly the phoenix has a Mary Sue element to it, but it is intrinsically a much more interesting concept than, say, the ki-rin or coautl, especially given the somewhat melancholic, even tragic nature of its death-and-rebirth cycle.

Interestingness: 4 bec de corbins, originality: 3 bec de corbins, usefulness: 3 bec de corbins

Shedu (lesser and greater) - The Shedu is cursed with an even worse-looking piece of art than that for the lammasu. In fact it may be one of the worst pieces of D&D art in existence. Even the designers seem to have struggled with this one - almost the entire description consists of reams of psionic abilities. Shedu, wait for it, can also, er, fly and do telepath...zzzzz

Interestingness: 1 bec de corbin, originality: 1 bec de corbin, usefulness: 2 bec de corbins

Androsphinx - The androsphinx may not really be the best example of a Big Good Guy Monster, as their description reveals them to be, frankly, a bit twattish. They don't like female sphinxes because the latter are more intelligent, despise humans, hate riddles, and do little of note. They are like the Victor Meldrew of sphinxes. But they are Chaotic Good and satisfy the other criteria, so they have to be in the mix.

Interestingness: 2 bec de corbin, originality: 2 bec de corbin, usefulness: 1 bec de corbins

Titan - It is difficult to know exactly what to make of titans. They are, we are repeatedly told, 'godlike' and 'like gods', but 'not gods', albeit that they are 'in all ways godlike' and often 'mistake[n] for deities'. I'm glad to have cleared that up for you. They are like a giant 20th level fighter mixed with a giant 20th level cleric and a giant 20th level magic-user, with lots of other spell-like abilities thrown in, and especially deadly melee attacks. They each also have their own unique abilities, which the DM is presumably supposed to make up. They would be necessary to have in an Ancient Greece-themed campaign, I think. Otherwise, they fulfil a similar function to a storm giant, ancient gold dragon, and so on. 

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbin, originality: 2 bec de corbin, usefulness: 2 bec de corbins

Treant - You know what treants are. They're Treebeard. They are very powerful in a fight, and can control trees to aid them in battle. 'Treants (regardless of size) and treant-controlled trees can inflict structural damage when attacking a building or fortification.' So watch it, Saruman. 

Interestingness: 3 bec de corbins, originality: 1 bec de corbin, usefulness: 2 bec de corbins

THE RESULTS

The final ranking, averaging all of the marks across the three criteria for all Big Good Guy Monsters, is as follows. You may provide you own drum roll, possibly by tapping your fingers on the table in front of you:

1 = Couatl: 3.333 bec de corbins
1 = Ki-rin: 3.333 bec de corbins
1 = Phoenix: 3.333 bec de corbins
4 = Guardian Naga: 3 bec de corbins
4 = Reef Giant: 3 bec de corbins
6 = Storm Giant: 2.666 bec de corbins
7 = Djinni: 2.333 bec de corbins
7 = Titan: 2.333 bec de corbins
9 = Lammasu: 2 bec de corbins
9 = Werebear: 2 bec de corbins
9 = Treant: 2 bec de corbins 
12 = Androsphinx: 1.666 bec de corbins
12 = Firbolg: 1.666 bec de corbins
14 = Shedu: 1.333 bec de corbins

So there you have it. shedus are shit and should live in sheds. Couatls are cool, ki-rins kick ass, and phoenixes...er....pheel it. Here endeth the lesson, 

Tuesday, 13 October 2026

5e-splaining the OSR

I recently watched an interesting YouTube video in which Ben Milton and somebody I have not heard of before called Daði discuss, among other things, OSR lethality:


This apparently stems from another video which Daði, a 5e DM, made, in which he put forward some claims about OSR lethality and how it can lead to player disengagement. The thesis (which has some validity to it) is that high levels of PC turnover can make the entire exercise seem throwaway, and that also - I think this is just implied - there is a phoneybaloney 'I'm really tough because I play a form of elfgame in which characters die a lot' element to the OSR player base that gets very tiresome very quickly. 

In this conversation, Ben makes the useful claim that in the early levels (really just level 1) an OSR dungeon expedition is like a heist - the PCs are so fragile they are just trying to get in, get some treasure, and get out again. I had never heard of things put that way before, but it's really an excellent word for describing what an OSR campaign feels like at the table; the 'lived experience' of play at level 1 is, more or less, exactly that.

Ben goes on to point out, however, that as soon as PCs in an OSR game gain levels they become a lot less fragile. And the game indeed very rapidly moves through the gears. Being a murderhobo in Fantasy Fucking Vietnam is a very short phase. Once a PC is 4th level the campaign looks very different.

I think Milton is here hitting on a very important point which OSR enthusiasts tend to undersell. The reason why I like playing OSR D&D is not really because I'm METAL and like PCs dying. (Though I do really like the element of jeopardy that is present during the D&D-as-heist period of a campaign.) It is rather that, if anything, it gives the players a sense of achievement which games which presume plot-immunity cannot match. The feeling of having successfully navigated a level 1 PC to level 4 or so is truly satisfying because it is genuinely difficult and nothing is guaranteed. And this, if anything, I would suggest forges a greater and more geniune sense of connectedness to a PC than those generated by a more 'silver age' 5e playstyle.

That is, the central proposition - that 'your character doesn't matter' in an OSR game whereas it does in a 5e one - is, I think, based on a flawed premise that perhaps results from people not playing OSR campaigns of sufficient length. I have never found that characters 'don't matter' in OSR games. Rather, I have found that they start off by not mattering very much, but quickly become important by dint of how much energy and time and thought has been dedicated to trying to make sure they survive. They come to matter a great deal, and that is what the process of low-level play is really all about. 

There is a tendency, in other words, to slightly oversell the difference between people who like playing 'mainstream' D&D and those who prefer the OSR playstyle. No doubt there are important differences and we could, if we wanted to, spend a long time listing them all if it hadn't already been done to death in 2008. But the emphasis on the importance of character is not, I think, one of them. OSR players love their PCs too (once you get past the 'my veins are as cold as ice and I care nothing for your special snowflake character' shtick). It is just that the relationship between player and PC is forged during play rather than during the process of generating the character.

Friday, 9 October 2026

Get Busy Writing or Get Busy Dying

I have never read David Gemmell - his oeuvre somehow passed me by. But I have been inspired to do so by a recent article in the Telegraph which caught my eye. It is sadly paywalled, but here are the main bits:

David Gemmell is our greatest fantasy author since Tolkien – but is being written out of history

In 1976, journalist David Gemmell received the devastating news that, at age 27, he might be dying of cancer. “I felt ill. A lot of weight was gone. I was passing blood,” Gemmell would recall. “It’s not a nice thought, cancer of the kidneys.” 

There was a two-week wait until the tests came back. It was the longest fortnight of Gemmell’s life, during which he did not know whether he would live or die. But rather than brood, he sat at his typewriter and wrote what was to become one of the most important British fantasy novels of the Eighties, the gritty blockbuster eventually published as Legend. 

Gemmell did not, as it turned out, have cancer. Yet those two weeks of sheer, existential terror would be the furnace in which was forged one of the most distinctive fantasy voices of his generation. More than distinctive: his grim, cynical take on the JRR Tolkien school of heroic storytelling arguably influenced subsequent generations of authors, not least Game of Thrones’s George RR Martin, whose unflinching style echoed Gemmell’s stark world-view. 

But today, at a time when fantasy is dominated by the gooey milieu of “romantasy”, there is a case to be made that Gemmell – whose worth is now being celebrated with a new collection – is not nearly as well known as he deserves and has even been written out of history. He was absent from Time’s 2020 countdown to the 100 Best Fantasy Novels of All Time and was also missing from a similar list published by Penguin Random House. Shockingly, a David Gemmell forum on Reddit clocks up just 1,000 weekly visits, while that for the Dungeon Crawler Carl series – the hot new saga in fantasy – has 275,000. Gemmell is the incredible shrinking giant of 20th-century fantasy. 
 
That’s despite an origin story almost every bit as striking as Tolkien’s admission that the opening lines of The Hobbit came to him in a delirium of boredom whilst he was marking exam papers. In the shadow of his cancer scare, Gemmell had written the first draft of Legend in two weeks – but left the ending open-ended. The novel was a metaphor for his illness, with the flinty hero Druss (modelled on his stepfather Bill Woodford) and sidekick Rek (an insert for the author) defending the crumbling fortress of Dros Delnoch against invading hordes of the Nadir – who symbolised the cancer he believed was ravaging his body. 

“It was so terrifying at that period – the only thing I could do to take my mind off the fear of dying was to write. I created a decaying fortress under siege from a terrible enemy,” he later said. “The idea was I would write in the two weeks I was waiting for the tests. If I had cancer, the fortress would fall.”

...


He was in his way, as significant a figure as Tolkien, says fantasy author James Worrad... “Someone once called him ‘English fantasy’s second wind’ and there’s some truth to that,” he tells me. “If you stand back far enough away it’s Tolkien and Gemmell you can make out, jutting up from the genre’s landscape like two mountains.”

I am sure that Gemmell's original draft of Legend was far from perfect, full of holes and inconsistencies, and read badly. But still - the idea of just sitting down and writing out a whole novel in two weeks is both an intimidating and inspiring prospect. Anybody can write a novel. You just need to sit down and write a novel. So why don't people do it more? Why haven't I done it? Why haven't you?

These thoughts chime with others inspired by an interview with Steve Jackson, of UK Games Workshop/Fighting Fantasy fame, which I recently read. In it, he describes how the other Steve Jackson, the American Stave Jackson associated with GURPS and The Fantasy Trip and others, came to London and ended up writing a fighting fantasy book:

Steve had flown over to London from Texas to talk to Ian and I about Games Workshop distributing his games in Europe. We’d mentioned Fighting Fantasy and how well it was doing. We also mentioned that competing publishers were beginning to publish their own gamebooks and, in response to this, Puffin wanted to publish a new gamebook every month. There was no way Ian and I could write an adventure a month, so we’d decided to sign up other authors to create new FF books. Anyway, the business side of things was sorted quite quickly. So we then asked Steve if he’d like us to take him to Stonehenge, or the Tower of London – all the places Americans want to see in the UK. But no. He didn’t want to go anywhere. He just asked for a desk and a typewriter. And he spent the next 3 days writing a Fighting Fantasy book!

That book apparently became Scorpion Swamp, which came out not long after. I am not sure whether he wrote the whole thing in three days, of course. But still - he did write it. He just sat down and did it. Anybody, in other words, can write a gamebook. You just need to sit down and write a gamebook.

Let me repeat, for the avoidance of doubt: anybody can write anything they like. You just need to write it. So what are you waiting for? What am I waiting for? What's stopping me? What's stopping you?

Thursday, 8 October 2026

Lego Faces and the Death of Freeform Play

 


One of the saddest and strangest developments of my lifetime has been the gradual replacement of the generic Lego smiley face with those displaying fixed cartoonish expressions of various kinds. OK, it's not quite the invasion of Iraq or the 2008 financial crisis or rising inflation. But you know what I mean.

Let's take a step back for a moment in order to explain. I would like to coin a new word for you now: the word I am going to coin is genericism.

genericism, n.

The favouring of the standard, or the general; the avoidance of the specific, or the varied. 

Genericism has its benefits and its pitfalls - it is not a virtue in itself. But when it comes to toys which are to be used in imaginative play, it is important, because it allows the child (or the grown man or woman, indeed) to project whatever he or she wants into the toy in question. If all Lego faces are blandly smiling, then that is tantamount to them having any facial expression whatsoever, or none at all. They can therefore be angry, sad, happy, upset, tired, or whatever, depending on how they are being imagined in the moment. The fact that they are all generically blandly smiling means they can all readily be something else in the mind's eye.

However, when some or all Lego faces have distinctive facial expressions - when genericism is repudiated - this has the effect, perversely, of making them harder to play with. It is not impossible, of course, to imagine that this Lego figure with the permanently angry/scared/tired face is not angry/scared/tired in any given moment within the context of imaginative play. But it nonetheless feels awkward. It requires more of an imaginative leap. Within the mind's eye, the angry-faced Lego figure is angry. And it is harder to picture them as being scared, tired, or anything else.

Another way of putting this is that while the Lego creators seem to have deliberately walked down a path towards what they think of as creative variance, what they have actually really done is blandify their product. They have stopped thinking about it as a toy and instead chosen to focus on what looks good. It is hard to avoid the conclusion that this is deliberate - that the 'faceification' of Lego figures, if I can call it that, is part of a wider shift away from imagining Lego as a toy and re-conceiving it as a collectable that mostly sits on shelves looking nice. If so, it is perhaps to be expected, but rather a shame. And it is connected to something that I think is rather sad about modern childhood itself: all around me I notice that children's opportunities to use their imaginations are being squeezed. Lego ought to be one at the forefront of the battle against this. But the company seems not particularly to care.